Of course ‘adults’ have no right to object to school climate strikes

Valentin Flauraud / EPA

Seriously. What did people think would happen? That the youth of the world would read the predictions of  perhaps 12 more years of sustainable life on planet earth and just do what adults did when they heard the news? Shrug and order another martini? Or latte? 

Sorry, but that is fucking stupid. It is stupid to think they would not fight back and stupid to think that they alone will ‘save us’ from ourselves. 

Do people really think the Davos Dandies are ignoring these predictions? Anyone who has anything is already busy planning for a new world.

They could not care less whether that new world includes ‘us’ or not.

If you are not part of the money-making machinery you are not part of the money-making solution.

And who is less a part of the shareholder fantasy than the youth of the world? 

So yes, they are starting to fight back. Most of us who have had children have taught them to fight back and to stand up for themselves.

It is naive to think they won’t put down their cell phones at some point and do what some of us did in the 70s: fight back in earnest.

Only we fought the system and lost. They are fighting for planet earth. They cannot afford to lose this battle. 

But please, don’t be too surprised if they ultimately begin concentrating on saving themselves rather than the rest of us. Or the Davos Dandies. 

Would  anyone blame them? This is our mess. We created it. We ignored it. We left it to them to mop it up. 

And we are still doing that very thing. Leaving it to them to fix it. How idiotic is that?

James Porteous

14 Feb 2019 | | The Conversation

“A worldwide wave of school climate strikes, begun by the remarkable Greta Thunberg, has reached the UK. Some critics claim these activist-pupils are simply playing truant, but I disagree. Speaking as both a climate campaigner and an academic philosopher, I believe school walkouts are morally and politically justifiable.

Philosophy can help us tackle the question of whether direct action is warranted via the theory of civil disobedience. This states that, in a democratic society, one is justified in disobeying the law only when other alternatives have been exhausted, and the injustice being protested against is grave.

In the case of the climate school strikes, it is without question that the injustice – the threat – is grave. There is none graver facing us.

It appears reasonable to claim furthermore that other alternatives have indeed been exhausted. After all, people have been trying to wake governments up to the climate threat for decades now, and we are still as a society way off the pace set out even by a conservative organisation such as the IPCC.

But if that claim was strongly contested, and it was suggested that climate activism should continue to focus on conventional electoral politics, then attention might revert to the assumed premise that society is democratic. Do people in Britain and elsewhere really live in “democracies”, given (for instance) the vastly greater power of the rich, and of owners of media, to influence elections, compared to everyone else?

A school strike in Melbourne, Australia. Julian Meehan / School StrikeCC BY-SA

I don’t want to adjudicate whether we really live in a democracy. But what of course makes this a particularly salient question for school strikes is the simple fact that in any case children have no voice in this democratic system. And yet the climate crisis and the perhaps equally catastrophic biodiversity crisis will affect children much more than adults.

Our “democratic” system seems to have a built in present-centricness, and a weakness in relation to issues of long-term significance, that seriously undermines its claims to democratic legitimacy. Thus philosophers have sometimes argued, beginning with Edmund Burke in the 18th century, that to make the system truly democratic we would need to somehow include – and give real power to – the voices of the past and the future in that system. Most especially, for they are at risk of suffering the worst: the voices of children and indeed of unborn future generations.

Read more: Why don’t teenagers have a greater say in their future?

So, a forceful argument could be made that it must be legitimate for children to take part in climate actions, for they do not even have recourse to the democratic channels (such as they are) that adults take for granted. This is especially true once we add that it seems reasonable for children to object to schooling that may well be rendered irrelevant by a climate-induced catastrophe. For example, much of the way that economics, business studies and IT are taught presupposes a world that will probably soon cease to exist.

Adults have failed

If you are convinced by this, then all well and good. However, at this point, I want to pull the rug slightly from under the argument that I’ve made so far. I put it to you that, if you are an adult, as I am, then your view in any case is somewhat beside the point.

Let down by adults? Young protesters at the recent UN climate talks in Poland. Andrzej Grygiel / EPA

For the brutal fact is that, try hard though some of us have done, we adults have categorically failed our children. This is a grievous wrong, perhaps the worst thing that mammals, primates, such as ourselves, can do: to have let down those who we claim to love more than life itself. We have set our children on a path to a “future” in which society as we know it may have collapsed. And even if we accomplish an unprecedented societal transformation over the next decade, the massive time-lags built into the climate system mean things will still get worse for a long time to come.

And so on this occasion we adults ought to humbly realise that it is no longer for us to tell our children what to do. We ought rather to take up the role of supporting them in their uprising, asking how we can help them in their struggle for survival. They are inspiring us, now.

The ultimate reason why we should support these school strikes, as I and hundreds of other UK academics have just declared we will do, is that, through our inaction that has led the world they will inherit to this pretty pass, we adults have forfeited the moral right to do anything else.

Original Link: School climate strikes: why adults no longer have the right to object to their children taking radical action

join the Hawkins Bay Revolution
before it is too late


James Porteous

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s